Türkçe Coming soon

Do babies look more like mom or dad? The research

Updated · Bebish

On average, neither. A well-known 1995 study reported that one-year-olds look more like their fathers, but later studies did not reproduce it. A baby gets half of their DNA from each parent, and strangers asked to match a child's photo to the right mom or dad do only a little better than chance.

Where does the idea that babies look like dad come from?

Mostly from a one-page report in Nature in 1995, Whose baby are you?, by Nicholas Christenfeld and Emily Hill. As a later paper describes it, they gathered photos from 24 families and asked judges to pick each child's parent out of three candidates. With one-year-olds, judges found the right father about 49 percent of the time, where guessing would give 33 percent, and they did worse with mothers.

The authors offered an evolutionary explanation. A mother knows the baby is hers and a father cannot be sure, so a baby who looks like him might get more of his care. It is a tidy story, and both scientists and the press gave it a lot of attention.

Did later studies confirm the father effect?

No. Serge Brédart and Robert French at the University of Liège expected to find the same thing and did not. They used photos from 28 families, showing the same child at ages 1, 3 and 5, and 180 students did the matching. At every age the students identified mothers about as well as fathers. Across the three ages they picked the right father 44.7 percent of the time, which means they were wrong more often than right. The authors concluded that the original result was most likely incorrect.

A 2007 study followed children from birth to age 6 and got a more tangled picture. Unrelated judges found that children resembled both parents more than chance would predict. Newborns of both sexes looked more like their mothers. Girls stayed that way, while boys came to resemble their fathers more between ages 2 and 3. The authors themselves describe the earlier evidence as contradictory.

So the studies do not agree with each other, and the two photo-matching experiments used pictures from fewer than 30 families each. What they have in common is that no clear, lasting advantage for dad shows up.

Why does everyone say the baby looks just like dad?

Possibly because people say it more often than the photos support. In the 2007 study, mothers of newborns said the baby took after the father, while outside judges looking at the same babies found the opposite.

Researchers have suggested this is a way of reassuring a new father. That is an interpretation, and nobody has proved the motive. It may be a kind thing people say in a delivery room. Either way, a family's verdict in the first week is not strong evidence.

Which facial features are inherited most strongly?

The nose, the chin and the area between the eyes, going by one large twin study. Researchers took 3D scans of 952 twins from the TwinsUK registry and compared identical with non-identical pairs. The areas under the strongest genetic control were the chin, the tip of the nose, the dip between the eyes at the top of the nose, the inner corners of the eyes and the groove between the nose and the upper lip. Nose width was among the most heritable measurements, at about 0.72 on a scale from 0 to 1. Much of the lip area scored lower.

Two cautions. All of the twins were adult women in the UK, so the map may not transfer neatly to other groups. And heritability says how much of the variation between people comes from genes. It says nothing about which parent a given child's nose will come from.

Does resemblance change as a child grows?

It seems to. In the Liège experiment, students matched 5-year-old boys to their parents more successfully than 1-year-old boys, with no such change for girls. The 2007 study saw boys move toward their fathers at around 2 to 3 years.

Neither study followed children past age 6, so nobody here can tell you what happens in the teenage years. What they do suggest is that the resemblance everyone argues about in the first weeks can look quite different by the first day of school. If your baby currently looks like nobody in particular, give it time.

Bebish plays with this exact argument. Before your portrait appears you lock in a guess of mom, dad or a mix, and afterward the app tells you whether it held up against the portrait it drew. That is a game about a drawing, and it says nothing about your real child's genes.

Sources

Meet your little one early

Add a photo of mom, a photo of dad and your ultrasound if you have one. Bebish draws a realistic portrait of your little one, usually in under a minute.

See how Bebish works

Questions parents ask

Do boys look like their mothers and girls like their fathers?

One study found something closer to the reverse. Outside judges rated newborn boys and girls as resembling their mothers more, girls stayed that way, and boys came to resemble their fathers more between ages 2 and 3. It is a single study, so do not lean on it too hard.

How good are people at telling whose baby it is from a photo?

Not very. In a 1999 experiment, students shown a child's face and three possible fathers picked the right one 44.7 percent of the time, against 33 percent by pure guessing. They did about as well with mothers.

Does a baby get more DNA from the mother or the father?

Half and half. MedlinePlus puts it plainly, half of a baby's DNA comes from the mother's egg and half from the father's sperm.

Why do relatives disagree about who the baby looks like?

Resemblance is judged by eye, and people do not see it the same way. In one study mothers said their newborns looked like the father, while unrelated judges looking at photos of the same babies saw more of the mother.

More guides